My account
log in
I don't have any Firestorm account
register

report : Training Dummy damage reduction

Report details

Status
Title : Training Dummy damage reduction
Status : 7
Creation date : March 16, 2016
Update date : July 27, 2016 16:41:02
expansion :
category : Classes
subcategory : - - -
Support : - - -
priority : normal
rating :
1 0
Training Dummy damage reduction
March 16, 2016 19:14:53

Traning dummies (http://www.wowhead.com/npc=87318/dungeoneers-training-dummy and http://www.wowhead.com/npc=87320/raiders-training-dummy ) have a damage reduction of 25% that they souldn't have.



Damage on a lvl 100 : 1293 (http://i.imgur.com/PYScF1W.jpg)

Damage on a lvl 103 : 1293 (http://i.imgur.com/d4M0kjL.jpg)

Damage on a dummy : 969 (http://i.imgur.com/38hOJeg.jpg)

969/1293=0.75 so 25% damage reduction.



This little problem gives wrong results on tests.
For exemple, my test on Chi Explosion (https://firestorm-servers.com/fr/report/see_report/5074) found a nerf of 25%, but this spell is correctly script.

Training Dummy damage reduction
March 19, 2016 14:05:27

J'ai remarqué ce problème aussi ! Tout mes tests étaient incohérents, maintenant en appliquant cette réduction de dégât c'est beaucoup mieux.

Training Dummy damage reduction
April 4, 2016 21:51:09

Test on bleeding effects which are not affect by armor
On dummy :
Rake : 1229 http://i.imgur.com/s96Ei53.jpg
Rake (DoT) : 1235 http://i.imgur.com/UFKe4Kn.jpg

On a lvl 100 :
Rake : 1639 http://i.imgur.com/893b7io.jpg
Rake (DoT) : 1647 http://i.imgur.com/JDX1jrw.jpg

1229/1639= 0.75
1235/1647= 0.75

It's a 25% nerf too.



Test on physical damage (auto-attack). Damage reduction on dummy should be 25% ( http://eu.battle.net/wow/fr/forum/topic/17288710373 )
I translate Lazio's post: "The physical damage reduction due to armor of bosses is therefore nearby 25%"
Here i do between 1520 and 1698 http://i.imgur.com/Dqpeju1.jpg

Let's calculate theorycal damage. I have 3624 Pa, 10% damage bonus do to strance and 4,8% versatility. My weapon attack speed is 2, and his damage area is [634 ; 952].
min_auto= (634+3624*2/3.5)*1.1*1.048= 3118
max_auto=(952+3624*2/3.5)*1.1*1.048= 3495
Theorycal damage on dummy is:
min damage: 3118*0.75=2338
max damage: 3495*0.75=2621

1520/2338=0.65
1698/2621=0.65
Physical damage have a big problem on the dummy too, only 0.49% on the non-reduced damage, so the dummy reduce the damage taken by 51% and not only 25%.

Note: Versatility isn't compute on the tooltips of the auto-attack damage.

Training Dummy damage reduction
April 4, 2016 22:23:09

On the lvl 102 dummy physical damage are reduced by 50%.

Proof: http://i.imgur.com/9znFe8O.jpg
Real damage : [1620 ; 1819]

Damage without reduction : [3240 ; 3644] (see the formula applied above with my new stats to compute this damage area)

Damage reduction:
1620/3240=0.5
1819/3644=0.5

Training Dummy damage reduction
April 13, 2016 21:07:55

Super important à corrigé rapidement ! des debugs classe sont effectués sur se bug ce qui engendre de faux correctif avec trop de dégât.

Training Dummy damage reduction
April 14, 2016 13:19:46

Little update: this issue is only for ally dummies, no such problem on the horde ones (thank you Netrakan).

Training Dummy damage reduction
May 18, 2016 13:35:35

Up !

Training Dummy damage reduction
July 27, 2016 16:41:02

Should be fixed by now