report : Intimidating Shout

status changed from new report to report confirmed

10%? Way more but it should break on 3-4% dmg. Retail fears break on 2 dot ticks

"but currently it's breaking after dealing about 10%~ damage to the target"
Lol way more more then 10% , here you can fear the main target , apply mortal strike and collosus smash without breaking it.
It rly break like when you receive dmg like 2-3% dmg of you life.
"Should have a low chance of breaking"
There is nothing about RNG on this spell , warriors fear are not strong as others fear , you can also watch all the blizzforum post where warriors are crying i bet you already find them .
It must break when you receive 2-3% dmg thats all, no such thing as "lowchance"

10% ? A warrior got me from 180k hp to 0k, 80k slam, 40k slam and 90k execute. Fear didn't break.. Had like 500k max hp

Senyha , i really want this bug fear to be fixed , but spreading lie is not gonna help us. Dont abuse on the number

It happened to me, that's why I say it. It doesn't break after 10%, thats like 1 slam..

Please, don't lie. It DOES break after taking 10% of damage and this is the evidence. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=22a47QvyFro

2 question
Did you record this with a potato ??
So your evidence is a record for Firestorm ?
Its should break less then 10% , we know thats it break at 10% or sometime even more thx you captain obvious.

from * dddddddddd

You did 130k and the fear is supposed to break on 10% of the mobs health so basicaly 55.3k but what if the fear break with 20% of the mob health ? 110k but you did 130k crit so you still did more damage than the break point so the fear break anyway. So your video is not a proof it's just a useless video :)

Do the same with an attack who can do less than 60k damage or a slam non crit on the same mob and we will see a real statement with a real difference.

Open your eyes and watch second strike. The video is full HD so no, it's not a potato. And I did this video to stop the retarded people from "OMFG WARR FEAR NO BREAK I TAKE 300K AND DIE IN ONE FEAR" so yeah this will be my evidence that it does break after taking 10% of damage. If you want to prove that I'm wrong, go ahead and present an evidence.

Test it in PvP in arena maybe, it's funny how me and my warrior friend did 2v2 yesterday and he did a fear at like 150k hp and it needed 3 hits from the warrior (colossus, mortal strike, slam) + some crackling jade lightning hits to break.

Try it on a player , not pve

Spell mechanics like this works same for PvP as PvE. You're free to present an evidence else I will consider it as lies.

Celestial alignement was working fine in pve. But doing 320k in PvP is not considered balanced. Anyway take you freaking video : It's nothing. As i explain, you're doing a 130k crit on a 555k mob.

10% or 555k is 55k. You doing almost 3times the damage required to break the fear and you say it's normal. Just think you dumbo. If you use a technique who is doing 60k on that mob and it breaks, fine. But 130k crit --' 130k is 10% of 555k ?????
Use your head.

Can't figure out if you're retarded or blind. Can't you see the second fear broke after dealing 50k (+auto attack) to the mob? https://youtu.be/22a47QvyFro?t=20s

You did 16k ( auto attacks ) + 50k ( Mastery Proc ) on that mob which equals 66k. Maybe you should get glasses and stop saying bullshit stuff sometimes. And learn the game too.

http://wow.gamepedia.com/Intimidating_Shout
Seriously the only reason why they switched this spell to disorient effect was to remove it from DR of fear
This "Any damage taken by the target will break the effect, even that caused by DoTs such as [Deep Wounds]. The fear affecting the additional enemies is less likely to break upon damage." apply to everypatch , This fear is the weakest fear of the game since it's physical school . In vanilla , bc , tlk , cata , mop , wod , IT MUST BREAK INSTANTLY when we receives dmg from this. Stop saying your casual bullshit about " it was changed to wod blablabla" it was only to change the type of DR

CochonHalal is right here and it's honestly a pity, that the Dev Team still considers questionable evidence from the evidently bugged server as proof, furthermore from people that have about as much experience about the in-depth background information of classes, mechanics and the likes, as a rotten fruit. While those that actually have that amount of experience get kicked from the Team for suggesting sensible fixes, based on their in-depth Retail experience and theorycrafting. ;)

TL;DR: Don't be a stupid fuck, IS has always and will always break from any kind of damage on the primary target and has a chance to break on the secondary targets.

TL;DR²: Please, for the love of god and all that is holy, you have a bugged server. Only take evidence from old retail vids, databases or other reliable sources. If the Database was "Retail-quality", like Lynix said to me, there wouldn't be a need for this senseless discussion or Class Masters to begin with. Get your heads out of the sands, slaves.

You got kicked for non-respect regarding the staff nothing to see with cm work.

https://youtu.be/wpB7dpF1XFk 05:49 the shaman got his fear broke almost instantly to the dots.

Because the warlock, the shaman take 50k~ damage, just like the video who post here Axantaa

The video posted by Axantaa isnt a proof for fqck sake , it was recorded on Firestorm omg

This should be fixed :)
Intimidating Shout, Fear and Ring of Frost effect will now break at a random damage value between 1 (instant break) and 10% of the caster heal (which means it WILL break after at most 10% of the max health you had when you got CC'd).

status changed from report confirmed to fix need test

je ne ces pas si vous avec teste guerrier en pvp ces drole ne tien pas 2 minute et peur en vois le personnage . de loutre couté et en le vois tous jour sur la meme map

then u gotta fix hunter's traps, druid's roots etc in a same way, cus they didnt break after 30% HP gone on Firestorm too.

then u gotta fix hunter's traps, druid's roots etc in a same way, cus they didnt break after 30% HP gone on Firestorm too.

Hunter traps work correctly.

status changed from fix need test to resolved

Assigned to Kr66